Independent Engineering Transfer After Traceable Generative-AI-Assisted Learning: A Six-University Controlled Trial with Deterministic Cluster Allocation in Agricultural Engineering Education
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
applied sciences
Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) can support engineering problem solving, but
whether AI-assisted practice transfers to independent performance after the tool is removed
remains unclear. This multicentre controlled trial evaluated a traceable five-stage GenAI
assisted learning configuration in agricultural engineering education. Twenty-eight second
and third-year classes from six universities in Uzbekistan were assigned within nine teacher
blocks by deterministic constrained minimization to GenAI (14 classes) or structured active
control (14 classes) groups. Both groups completed the same 16-week module, tasks,
software, contact time, feedback, and verification requirements. They differed in the source
and adaptivity of a provisional alternative used after an independent attempt: bounded
adaptive GenAI dialogue versus a version-controlled curated alternative. The full assigned
cohort included 656 students; likelihood-based available-outcome analyses included 641 im
mediate and 589 delayed outcomes. Kenward–Roger analyses estimated an adjusted imme
diate difference of 2.78 points (95% confidence interval (CI) [2.02, 3.55]; p < 0.001; model
basedd=0.72)andadelayeddifferenceof2.34points(95%CI[1.54, 3.14]; p<0.001; d = 0.51).
The results show a positive adjusted association for the evaluated traceable instruc
tional configuration, but deterministic post-baseline allocation limits causal interpretation.